Some Story background
only the green modules will be compared in this article, we'll play with the others later on.
Signle Channel (1*2GB) and Dual-Channel (2*2GB) results are the following:
There is definitely a performance increase in pure RAM bandwidth, though this has barely any impact on real life work on a legacy PC.
NB: i also tried to mix the Corsair (5-5-5-18) and Nanya (6-6-6-18) modules, the motherboard set them to dual channel even though the chips are quite differents... and gave the following result:
It down-clocked the RAM to 667MHz (351MHz), and reduced latency to 5-5-5-15; for a 2410MB/s bandwidth.
With time going on, i got enough DDR2 modules to play a little with them.
An old question was how CAS latency is important and impacts performace on a legacy computer (with a CPU that doesn't feature any L3 cache)
An old question was how CAS latency is important and impacts performace on a legacy computer (with a CPU that doesn't feature any L3 cache)
Clock and CAS Latency
Modules used:
Modules used:
Name | PC2- | Frequency (MHz) | CAS latency | Size (MB) per module |
Nanya NT2GT64U8HD0BY-AD | 6400 | 800 | 6-6-6-18 | 2048 |
Corsair Value Select VS2GB800D2 | 6400 | 800 | 5-5-5-18 | 2048 |
Gskill Extrem2 PC6400PK | 6400 | 800 | 4-4-4-12 | 1024 |
Gskill Extrem2 PC6400HZ | 6400 | 800 | 4-4-4-12 | 512 |
Hynix HYMP564U64BP8-C4 AB-T | 4200 | 533 | 4-4-4-12 | 512 |
Micron MT8HTF6464AY-53EB3 | 4200 | 533 | 4-4-4-12 | 512 |
Testing Conditions
Hardware & Software
Hardware & Software
CPU : AMD Athlon X2 64 5600+ (@2.9GHz)
MotherBoard: Gigabyte GA-M61PME-S2P
RAM : Tested Criteria
GPU : Geforce 8400GS
HDD : Seagate Barracuda 7200.8 250 GB (7200rpm)
CD/DVD : writer
Floppy
MotherBoard: Gigabyte GA-M61PME-S2P
RAM : Tested Criteria
GPU : Geforce 8400GS
HDD : Seagate Barracuda 7200.8 250 GB (7200rpm)
CD/DVD : writer
Floppy
Results
Single and Dual Channel CAS battle (DDR800)
Both Modules are 2GB DDR800 (PC2-6400), the only discriminating criteria is the Cas Latency : CL5 (5-5-5-18) vs CL6 (6-6-6-18)Single and Dual Channel CAS battle (DDR800)
Signle Channel (1*2GB) and Dual-Channel (2*2GB) results are the following:
- SC-5-5-5-18: 2369MB/s
- SC-6-6-6-18: 2252MB/s
- DC-5-5-5-18: 2861MB/s
- DC-6-6-6-18: 2643MB/s
Upgrading from ↓ to → | Single Channel 5-5-5-18 | Dual Channel 5-5-5-18 |
Single Channel 6-6-6-18 | +5 % | |
Dual Channel 6-6-6-18 | +8 % |
There is definitely a performance increase in pure RAM bandwidth, though this has barely any impact on real life work on a legacy PC.
NB: i also tried to mix the Corsair (5-5-5-18) and Nanya (6-6-6-18) modules, the motherboard set them to dual channel even though the chips are quite differents... and gave the following result:
It down-clocked the RAM to 667MHz (351MHz), and reduced latency to 5-5-5-15; for a 2410MB/s bandwidth.
No comments:
Post a Comment